User login

Newsletter

Stay informed on our latest news!

Syndicate content

Recent comments

pr vs. journos

Mohamed Elzubeir's picture

Journalists continue to gripe over PR practitioners

Raji Amer

In today's (July 21, 2009) Al Watan daily from Qatar, there was an op-ed piece by Raji Amer. In it, he blasts PR companies for being unprofessional. His main gripe? Press releases that are not well written, forcing him to rewrite them. He says, essentially doing their job for them.

Mohamed Elzubeir's picture

How would it be if PR and Journos got along together?

I LOVE/HATE YOU

Can you imagine a world where PR practitioners and journalists were one happy family? Yes, like buddies! Before you start fantasizing further, allow me to point out that this would be the mother of all disasters for news.

I often find it funny how much attention is being given to the struggle between PR's and Journos. This isn't unique to our region. In fact, this is how it has always been (and shall remain); an eternal struggle for power. A quick google search confirms what I have long believed. These two groups are locked in it till the death. Hell, I would say long after that as well.

The very nature of the relationship dictates that it is a barely civil relationship, underneath which lies contempt and sometimes (but rarely) respect. Tala's article in the National, covered here started a conversation that is still happening. A public conversation, which surprisingly, still continues.

The most recent was the National's, Transparency drive strains media, PR relations, gets warmer in identifying the complexities of the relationship.

Journalists have the power to publish or not publish certain material and PR's sometimes want things to be published and others not.. their interests are for the most part in conflict of one another. They are, by definition, rivals! This is not to even get into the "PR's don't know how to do their job" to "journalists who can't even write" arguments. Beneath it all, it is a mere pull and push war going on between the two sides.

I say, let it continue. The more balanced the scales are (and I prefer them to favor the journalists) the better. All that is happening now is that journalists are starting to gain some of that control. The status quo is changing. Is it the drive for transparency or is it more than that?

Twitter Feed

  • @RTA_Dubai thanks a lot. Just got a parking fine. So much for #mpark #fail #suck 14 hours 28 min ago
  • Govt officials who give lip service to 'getting out of the way' need to look in the mirror #adms #bs 15 hours 29 min ago
  • Tantawi dies, finally... http://short.to/1gm6h 17 hours 45 min ago
  • Enough with the iPhone crap already. #theNational changed mobile theme to look like an iPhone. Really? Ugh! 18 hours 5 min ago
  • Google is getting too big that I'm actually happy for Microsoft. Imagine that! http://short.to/1h9bh 18 hours 20 min ago